ECJ: VAT on abort costs fully deductible

VAT on abort costs in case of an unsuccessful takeover bid is deductible, provided the buyer intended to supply management services for consideration to the target company. This was ruled by the Court of Justice of the European Union (“CJEU”) in the Ryanair case (C-249/17) issued on 17 October 2018.

Facts of the case

Ryanair attempted to acquire a 100% shareholding of Aer Lingus. Although the takeover was unsuccessful, Ryanair sought to recover the entire input VAT on professional advisory fees incurred. Ryanair argued that it intended to provide management services to Aer Lingus, had the takeover been successful. The question arose whether the input VAT on the abort costs could be fully deducted.


The CJEU considered that in order to determine whether VAT on costs is deductible, the reason for the expenditure must be determined. As Ryanair intended to pursue an economic activity with the acquisition of Aer Lingus, namely the supply of VAT taxed management services, the abort costs were incurred for this purpose. Hence, these costs are directly and immediately linked to an economic activity (i.e. the provision of management services). As a result, Ryanair is entitled to deduct VAT on these costs, even though ultimately no management services were provided.


The deduction of VAT on costs incurred in relation to share transactions is often a topic of discussion with various European tax authorities. The Ryanair case confirms the deduction of VAT on costs incurred for the acquisition of shares, provided that the acquiring entity can demonstrate a clear intention to provide VAT taxable services to the target company. The M&A practice is therefore greatly benefitted by this judgment. The judgment may provide arguments for higher deduction of VAT on abort costs in particular for taxpayers generally not entitled to a full deduction of VAT (for example due to VAT exempt financing activities).

Related : Loyens & Loeff Luxembourg S.à r.l. ( Mr. Thierry Charon )

[+ http://www.loyensloeff.com]

Click here to see the ad(s)
All articles VAT

Lastest articles VAT

VAT Circular on transactions between related parties

On 19 January 2019, the Luxembourg VAT authorities published Circular 790(“Circular”) to clarify Article ...

VAT Circular on transactions between related parties Read more

VAT Circular on transactions between related parties

On 18 January 2019, the Luxembourg VAT authorities published a new Circular (N°790), which clarifies the provisions of...

Read more

New tax measures revealed in the coalition agreement published by the future government – ATAD Bi...

Further to the elections for Parliament held in October this year, the former ruling coalition between the liberal, ecolog...

Read more

Brexit relocations: The view from CMS Luxembourg

Luxembourg’s well-established reputation as a leading financial centre makes it a natural candidate for financial co...

Read more

Lastest articles by Mr. Thierry Charon

CJEU: VAT on share disposal costs recoverable in certain cases

VAT on costs incurred in connection with an envisaged share disposal is in principle not recoverable. However, if the reas...

Read more

EU Commission warns stakeholders of customs and indirect tax impact of Brexit

On 30 January 2018, the EU Commission issued a notice regarding the impact of Brexit in the field of customs and...

Read more

EU Commission proposes legislation on modernising VAT for cross-border e-commerce

On 1 December 2016, the European Commission (“the Commission”) proposed changes to the EU VAT Directive for cr...

Read more

New details on the Director fees subject to Luxembourg VAT

The Luxembourg VAT Authorities published, on 30 September 2016, a long-awaited clarification regarding the Luxembourg VAT ...

Read more

LexGO Network