LexGo

Parent-Subsidiary Directive not applicable to Gibraltar companies
15/04/2020

ON 2 APRIL 2020, THE EUROPEAN COURT OF JUSTICE (“ECJ”) (CASE C-458-18) RULED THAT A COMPANY INCORPORATED IN GIBRALTAR AND SUBJECT TO GIBRALTAR CORPORATION TAX CANNOT BE CONSIDERED TO BE A “COMPANY OF A MEMBER STATE” WITHIN THE MEANING OF COUNCIL DIRECTIVE 2011/96/EU OF 30 NOVEMBER 2011 ON THE COMMON SYSTEM OF TAXATION APPLICABLE IN THE CASE OF PARENT COMPANIES AND SUBSIDIARIES OF DIFFERENT MEMBER STATES (“PARENT-SUBSIDIARY DIRECTIVE”).

The case concerned the distribution of dividends during the period July 2011 to April 2016 by a Bulgarian company to its parent company established in Gibraltar. The Bulgarian tax authorities refused to exempt such dividends from withholding tax, considering that the Gibraltar company did not meet the conditions of Article 2 of the Parent-Subsidiary Directive (this directive gives an exhaustive definition of its scope, and does not expressly include Gibraltar companies subject to corporation tax in Gibraltar).

The question ultimately brought before the ECJ was whether the phrases “companies incorporated under the law of the United Kingdom” and “corporation tax in the United Kingdom” should be interpreted as designating companies incorporated in Gibraltar subject to corporation tax in Gibraltar for the purposes of the Parent-Subsidiary Directive.

Citing the opinion from the General Advocate, for reasons of legal certainty, the ECJ considered that the scope of the Parent-Subsidiary Directive cannot be extended by analogy to companies other than those included in the exhaustive list (Part A of Annex I to the directive).

As regards the United Kingdom, the Parent-Subsidiary Directive applies only to “companies incorporated under the law of the United Kingdom” and subject to “corporation tax in the United Kingdom”. Gibraltar constitutes a European territory and the United Kingdom (a Member State for the period under reference) is responsible for its external relations.According to the Government of the United Kingdom, companies formed in accordance with its national law do not include companies incorporated in Gibraltar. In addition, tax levied in Gibraltar does not constitute “corporation tax in the United Kingdom”.

The ECJ concluded by deciding that the concepts “companies incorporated under the law of the United Kingdom” and “corporation tax in the United Kingdom” within the Parent-Subsidiary Directive (Article 2(a)(i) and (iii) read in conjunction with Part A and Part B of Annex I) do not cover companies incorporated in Gibraltar which are subject to corporation tax there.

The ECJ specified that this conclusion is without prejudice to the obligation to comply with Articles 49 and 63 TFEU and to ascertain whether the taxation of profits distributed by a Bulgarian subsidiary to its parent company established in Gibraltar constitutes a(n unjustified) restriction with regard to the right of establishment or the free movement of capital enjoyed by companies incorporated in Gibraltar.

The ECJ decision contrasts with the previous interpretation adopted by many EU Member States and by the EU Commission. Its actual consequences in Luxembourg and abroad will have to be monitored in due course.

Zie ook : Arendt ( Mr. Eric Fort ,  Mr. Alain Goebel )

[+ http://www.arendt.com]

Mr. Eric Fort Mr. Eric Fort
Partner
eric.fort@arendt.com
Mr. Alain Goebel Mr. Alain Goebel
Partner
alain.goebel@arendt.com

Click here to see the ad(s)
Alle artikels Vennootschapsbelasting

Laatste artikels Vennootschapsbelasting

DAC6 and CRS deadline extensions – Update
05/06/2020

Yesterday, the Luxembourg Finance Ministry reported that EU Member States have agreed on a compromise proposal for a Direc...

Read more

The modification of a vertical tax consolidation group into a horizontal tax consolidation group ...
19/05/2020

On 14 May 2020, the Court of Justice of the European Union (“CJEU”) ruled on the Luxembourg tax consolidation ...

Read more

European Commission requests Luxembourg to amend its tax rules on foreign securitisation enterpri...
18/05/2020

Yesterday (15 May), the European Commission sent 2 letters of formal notice to Luxembourg relating to securitisation, one ...

Read more

DAC 6 reporting obligations starting as from 1 October 2020
12/05/2020

On 8 May 2020, as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic, the EU Commission proposed a three-month postponement of the starting...

Read more

Laatste artikels van Mr. Eric Fort

DAC 6 reporting obligations starting as from 1 October 2020
12/05/2020

On 8 May 2020, as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic, the EU Commission proposed a three-month postponement of the starting...

Read more

New Luxembourg bill on payments to EU ‘black-list’ countries
06/04/2020

On 30 March 2020, the Luxembourg government filed Bill of law No 7547 implementing certain guidelines approved by the...

Read more

DAC 6 Law introducing mandatory disclosure rules in Luxembourg passed
25/03/2020

On Saturday 21 March 2020, the Luxembourg Parliament passed a law implementing Council Directive (EU) 2018/822 of 25 May 2...

Read more

EU ECOFIN: revision of the EU list of non-cooperative jurisdictions for tax purposes
19/02/2020

The Economic and Financial Affairs Council (ECOFIN) today adopted revised conclusions on the EU list of non-cooperative ju...

Read more

Laatste artikels van Mr. Alain Goebel

DAC 6 reporting obligations starting as from 1 October 2020
12/05/2020

On 8 May 2020, as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic, the EU Commission proposed a three-month postponement of the starting...

Read more

New Luxembourg bill on payments to EU ‘black-list’ countries
06/04/2020

On 30 March 2020, the Luxembourg government filed Bill of law No 7547 implementing certain guidelines approved by the...

Read more

DAC 6 Law introducing mandatory disclosure rules in Luxembourg passed
25/03/2020

On Saturday 21 March 2020, the Luxembourg Parliament passed a law implementing Council Directive (EU) 2018/822 of 25 May 2...

Read more

EU ECOFIN: revision of the EU list of non-cooperative jurisdictions for tax purposes
19/02/2020

The Economic and Financial Affairs Council (ECOFIN) today adopted revised conclusions on the EU list of non-cooperative ju...

Read more

LexGO Network