LexGo

The Court of Justice of the EU clarifies the assessment of position marks for services
15/10/2020

The Court of Justice of the EU recently clarified the criteria to take into account when assessing the distinctive character of a position mark applied for in respect of services, in this case passenger transport services (CJEU Östgötatrafiken judgment, Case C-456/19).

Since 2003, the Swedish urban transport company Östgötatrafiken has held several figurative trade marks, which it affixes to its vehicles. In 2016, it applied for three new trade marks, described as “position marks”, consisting of coloured ellipses of different sizes placed in a certain position on buses and trains.

The Swedish Trade Mark Office refused registration on the ground that the shape and colours of the signs did not depart significantly from those used by other transport undertakings on the market to decorate their vehicles, meaning they would not be perceived by the public as an indication of origin. The Stockholm trial court confirmed the refusal of registration.

At the appellate level, however, the Stockholm Court of Appeal sought a preliminary ruling from the Court of Justice, as it was reluctant to apply to services the strict criterion used to assess whether the shape of a product is distinctive, namely whether it constitutes a significant departure from the standard or habits of the sector. In this case, the coloured motifs are affixed in a particular way to buses and trains used to provide transport services, but the shape of the vehicles is not per se the subject of the trade mark applications.

The Court of Justice confirmed that the public perceives the coloured motifs as being affixed to the vehicles, which serve as their exclusive medium, and that this perception must be taken into account. However the Court held that “it is not necessary to examine whether the signs for which registration as a trade mark is sought depart significantly from the norm or customs of the economic sector concerned”. The signs at issue are not indissociable from the shape or packaging of the goods, nor do they represent the layout of a physical space in which services are provided (as was found to be the case with the interior of an Apple store; Case C-421/13).

Therefore, it is now up to the Stockholm Court of Appeal to reassess the signs in question, without taking into account the criterion applicable to three-dimensional trade marks wrongly applied to the signs at stake by the Swedish Trade Mark Office and the lower court.

Zie ook : Nautadutilh Avocats Luxembourg Sàrl ( Mr. Vincent Wellens )

[+ http://www.nautadutilh.com]

Mr. Vincent Wellens Mr. Vincent Wellens
Partner
[email protected]

Alle artikels Europees recht

Laatste artikels Europees recht

New step towards the adoption of the public country-by- country reporting (CBCR) directive
07/06/2021

On 1st June, the EU Council reached a provisional political agreement with the European Parliament’s negotiating tea...

Read more

Political agreement reached on public country-by-country reporting
03/06/2021

On 1 June 2021, the Council of the European Union (the “Council”) reached a political agreement with the Europ...

Political agreement reached on public country-by-country reporting Read more

Europe’s new Chief Prosecutor has her hands full from the outset
02/06/2021

On 1 June 2021, the first supranational public prosecution authority, the European Public Prosecutor’s Office (&ldqu...

Read more

La CJUE sanctionnée
01/06/2021

Le Contrôleur Européen de la Protection des Données (EDPS) a reçu une plainte d’une perso...

La CJUE sanctionnée Read more

Laatste artikels van Mr. Vincent Wellens

Insufficient cybersecurity measures under GDPR: 100k EUR fine in Belgium & key fines elsewhere
29/04/2021

On 26 April 2021, the Litigation Chamber of the Belgian Data Protection Authority (BDPA) handed down its first fine specif...

Read more

Regulatory changes in the audiovisual media sector
16/04/2021

The Act of 26 February 2021 and certain grand ducal regulations have transposed into Luxembourg law the Audiovisual Media ...

Read more

New bill brings Luxembourg to the forefront of distributed ledger technology
17/03/2021

On 22 January 2021 Parliament approved Bill 7637, which modified:  the Law of 5 April 1993 on the financial sec...

Read more

The Sky Is Not the Limit: Space Activities in Luxembourg
15/02/2021

At the end of 2020, Luxembourg adopted the Act of 15 December 2020 on space activities (loi du 15 décembre 2020 por...

Read more

LexGO Network